The morality of delirium discussed in new BBC podcast: listen
The return of clubs and nightlife to the UK after last month’s so-called ‘Freedom Day’ was the subject of recent discussion on BBC Radio 4’s ‘Moral Maze’.
Last week, a panel of philosophers and writers gathered on the live debate program to discuss the clubs and, in particular, the morality of the party.
The panel consisted of Novara Media reporter Ash Sarkar, Times columnist Melanie Phillips, historian Tim Stanley and priest Giles Fraser. “There is a balance to be struck between freedom and responsibility,” said Michael Buerk, who chaired the discussion, in the introduction to the program, where he presented the discussion as forming around “the moral value of celebration.” .
The debate lasted around 40 minutes and saw the panelists, along with a number of additional personalities, address various current talking points amid the COVID-19 pandemic, such as vaccine passports and other clubbing restrictions, the wasted time of clubbers, and the moral of partying after the pandemic.
Ash Sarkar, posing as “a member of the far left party,” said: “I can’t stand this current of intellectualism that watches people have fun and has decided that making fun of them is the best way. to prove how smart and worldly you are. Personally, I believe that there is beauty in a crowd and, besides, in a nightclub, it is not about individualism or atomization is a collective experience that goes beyond oneself and creates something, an atmosphere, a wave of joy with others. “
Sarkar also brushed off comments from other panel members comparing classical musicians such as Beethoven to current electronic music, saying, “Listen to Floorplan and tell me there is nothing in there that is touching, transcendent. or even sublime. “
Approaching the debate from an opposite angle, Tim Stanley said, âI wouldn’t close nightclubs because I think you have a right to be dumb, but I’m generally wary of fun. I am wary of others having fun, because in In my experience this usually leads to noise and criminal damage. But I’m also suspicious of myself because I think partying is being stupid – I don’t see how you can be both stupid and moral. “
You can listen to the entire debate via BBC sounds.
Read DJ Mag’s recent article on how UK clubs and promoters are approaching a safe return to the dance floors after restrictions are lifted here.
– Ash Sarkar (@AyoCaesar) July 29, 2021